The Seeking Alpha ETF Investing Guide

This article has 22 comments:

•  
  hal stark

  Aug 09 03:11 PM
  Is this ETF guide available in book form or by e-mail?
  Thank you,
•  
  Ernest
  Harris

  Jun 16 02:46 PM
  Since there are now many more ETFs to choose from, do you plan to update the ETF Investing guide?
  16-June-2007
  
  Thanks
•  
  David
  Jackson

  Jul 17 05:34 PM

  My Website
  Ernest,
  
  We've just published a completely updated listing of ETFs with commentary -- the <b>ETF Selector</b>. Let me know if you have any feedback on it or suggestions.
  
  The Guide is basically up to date, because it discusses investment strategy rather than individual ETFs. The core portfolio probably needs updating though as some lower cost alternatives are now available, such as the new bond ETFs.
  
  Best,
  David
•  
  orangejuicev
  iiix

  Jul 17 11:32 AM
  Hi David,
  
  Will really appreciate it if you add a section on non-resident aliens (NRA) buying ETFs (or maybe stocks in general) in the US using US online brokerage. What are the possible tax implications of a NRA constructing an ETF portfolio?
  
  Thanks
•  
  David
  Jackson

  Jul 17 05:36 PM

  My Website
  Hi orangejuiceviiix,
  
  I must admit -- I know nothing about that subject, and I've tried to cushion all tax discussion in the Guide with a disclaimer of "check with your accountant". Sorry not to be more helpful.
  
  If you find someone to write that chapter, send them my way!
  
  David
•  
  Charlie
  Brown

  Jul 29 05:30 PM
  When I first read the ETF Investing Guide it struck a chord in me since I had been trying to find an investment strategy for many years. I had gone through various investment firms, had wrap accounts, a personal financial investor, and lost money in the dotcom crash. After reading the ETF IG I realized that I needed some tools to help implement converting the stocks and mutual funds that I had over into ETFs. So I created a simple 2 sheet excel spreadsheet with the first sheet containing all assets and what categories each asset fell into. The second sheet took the totals from the first sheet and plugged them into the Theoretical column (see example below). The only value the user inputs in the second sheet is the Stock percentage which in this case uses 70%. One could easily add the percentage over/under invested for any asset class that could act as a trigger when to rebalance the portfolio. It takes me about 20 minutes to update this information each quarter.
  
  Difference key: invest more 1,234 Goal Stock 0.70 324,800 Bonds 0.30 139,20
  invest less (1,234) Actual 0.69 318,700 0.29 145,300
  Difference 6,100 (6,100)
  
  ETF Fund Name Category Expense Percent Theoretical Actual Difference
  IVV iShares S&amp;P 500 Ind Fund Large Cap 0.09 17.50 81,200 212700 (131,500)
  IJH iShares S&amp;P Mid Cap 400 Mid Cap 0.20 17.50 81,200 11000 70,200
  IWM iShares Russell 2000 In Small Cap 0.20 17.50 81,200 35000 46,200
  EFA Ishares MSCI EAFE Ind Foreign 0.35 4.38 20,300 60000 (39,700)
  EEM Ishares MSCI Emerging Mk Emerging 0.75 4.38 20,300 0 20,300
  RWR street TRACTKS Wilshire REIT 0.25 4.38 20,300 0 20,300
  CASH Cash Cash 0.00 4.38 20,300 0 20,300
  
  LQD iShares GS Investop Corp Bd Bond Crp 0.15 12.00 55,680 74000 (18,320)
  SHY iShares Lehman 1-3 yr Tr Bd Bond Sh 0.15 12.00 55,680 44300 11,380
  IEF iShares Lehman 7-10 yr Tr Bond Lng 0.15 6.00 27,840 27000 840
  100.00 464,000 464000
  
  --Charlie
•  
  Charlie
  Brown

  Jul 29 05:33 PM
  Sorry about the data compression. I had everything spaced out nicely in columns but the spaces were removed when the comment was submitted.
  
  --Charlie
•  
  Jason
  Zirotti

  Aug 04 04:48 PM
  Charlie,
  
  Do you have a copy of that Excel doc (minus all of your personal info, obviously)? I would appreciate if you could shoot it my way!
  
  Cheers,
  
  zirotti at gmail dot com
•  
  Electricjosh
  ua

  Jan 07 11:30 PM
  What about Claymore ETFs?
•  
  thetrystero

  Mar 20 09:55 AM
  Hi Dave,
  
  Thanks for putting together this guide.
  I realize this is targeted mostly at my core portfolio, but I wonder what your views are with regards to retirement investments. Does the same apply, i. e. favor ETFs over mutuals? It seems that for most IRA accounts available now (Vanguard etc.) ETF seems (to me at least) to be a rather unconventional route. Is there a reason that retirement funds are focusing more on mutuals?
  
  
•  
  David
  Jackson

  Mar 26 12:20 PM

  My Website
  Thetrystero,
  
  Thanks for your kind comment.
  
  ETFs for retirement accounts are a fascinating issue. Most plan administrators don't offer ETFs, so you don't even have the option to use them. One reason might be that if you're adding small amounts regularly to your retirement account, the trading fees would take too large a bite out of your capital. On the other hand, since ETF fees are so low, they're well suited for long term investing like retirement accounts. For that reason, some companies are trying to pool ETF trades among multiple accounts to reduce or eliminate the trading fees.
  
  Not sure if that answers your question though...
  
  David
•  
  User 158820

  Apr 05 11:19 AM
  Hello Everyone
  I'm looking for a tool that I can pretty closely match a mutual fund's performace to a ETF in the same catagory and style. For example, I looking for an ETF that closely matches the mutual fund ECIGX.
  Thanks For The Help
  Dennis
•  
  User 158820

  Apr 05 11:21 AM
  Hello Everyone
  I'm looking for a tool that I can pretty closely match a mutual fund's performace to a ETF in the same catagory and style. For example, I looking for an ETF that closely matches the mutual fund ECIGX.
  Thanks For The Help
  Dennis
•  
  SMallick

  Apr 23 05:17 PM
  Hello everyone - the MacroShares Oil Up (UCR) and Oil Down (DCR) ETF's recently hit their early termination triggers and will be redeemed in June. Are you aware of any search tool that lists such triggers for other ETFs? Other than that it seems like the only option is to read the prospectus of every single ETF before trading.
•  
  autboy

  May 15 10:27 PM
  Wish I had taken this years ago. Alas...
•  
  valenna

  Jun 11 04:32 AM

  My Website
  The masters of the Internet business and leading experts of the world of all directions on the basis of the knowledge and experience have found the quintessence success through connection of creativity and an spirituality which gives a new direction in work, open new vision and forms the person of the future: creative, highly spiritual and self-sufficient.
•  
  User 25255

  Jun 28 11:01 AM
  Thanks! This guide is helpful and a great tool for those of us that need some direction on a passive strategy!
  
  Now if I could just read something that would teach me discipline.... I would be all set..
•  
  User 220206

  Jul 01 09:01 AM
  I'm looking for an inverse index Financials Sector FET. Any thoughts welcome.
•  
  PCScipio

  Jul 05 10:46 PM
  SKF is a double inverse Financials, but you may be rather late to the party.
•  
  murf-o

  Jul 08 12:16 PM
  How about market-neutral fund ? Check TFSMX
•  
  Albanian
  hotels

  Aug 10 06:53 AM

  My Website
  We manage 400 hotels around Albania and we would like to corporate with eny company.
•  
  User 25255

  Aug 11 10:01 PM
  David, I have one question. ( Maybe I missed it in the reading. )
  
  What about adding new contributions into the portfolio? If you add new funds in during rebalancing, then your percentages are thrown off and your triggers are no longer valid. Any recommendations on how to handle this? (other than buying a small amount of every ETF owned.)
  
  Thanks!